Suggestions
Explore the featured selections!
Fried Cheese
New York, New York Pizza
Pasta Combo Dish Lunch Special
Cannelloni Lunch Special
About
New York Pizza and Pasta
Welcome to New York Pizza and Pasta, a culinary gem nestled in Baton Rouge, Louisiana. This family-owned restaurant, located at 5380 Jones Creek Rd, has quickly become a favorite for locals and visitors alike. With a delightful array of artisanal pizzas and mouthwatering pasta dishes, New York Pizza and Pasta stands out as a notch above the conventional chain options.
As you step into the cozy atmosphere, you’ll be enveloped by a warm and welcoming environment where each guest is treated like family. The attentive staff is eager to ensure your dining experience is exceptional, contributing to the inviting ambiance that makes you want to linger.
Speaking of the food, it's nothing short of outstanding. A customer favorite is the meat lovers pizza, a 10-inch masterpiece that has received rave reviews for its bold flavors and quality ingredients. The supreme pizza has also garnered attention, winning over first-time patrons who are captivated by its rich toppings and perfect crust. Another highlight is their house salad, topped with a unique tomato basil vinaigrette that surprised even the most discerning palates.
But the culinary delights don’t stop at pizza. The extensive pasta menu features dishes like the Chicken Fettuccine Alfredo and the decadent Lobster Ravioli, both priced reasonably, ensuring dining out feels both indulgent and accessible. Guests rave about the homemade quality of the sauces, such as the authentic marinara and Alfredo sauce, which elevate each dish to a new level of excellence.
What truly sets New York Pizza and Pasta apart is the personal touch. Many customers note the owner’s presence, who personally greets and engages with guests, making everyone feel welcome. This personal connection reinforces a sense of community that's often lacking in larger chains, further solidifying this eatery's status in Baton Rouge's dining scene.
In summary, if you are in search of an authentic Italian culinary experience, look no further than New York Pizza and Pasta. From sumptuous pizzas to rich pasta dishes, delightful service, and a family-friendly atmosphere, this restaurant promises a memorable dining experience that leaves you eager to return for more. Come visit, and treat your taste buds—they won't be disappointed!
Book a table
Make A Reservation
“ I really wish I could give this restaurant more stars. Five just isn't enough. I started looking for a place to serve pizza that wasn't a chain like Domino's, Papa John's, or Pizza Hut. And this place popped up much to my delight. So the fam went for lunch and we got a 10-in meat lovers, an 18 in supreme and of course I had to try the house salad. I was kind of underwhelmed by the appearance of the tomato basil vinaigrette, but I was going to try it regardless. It was amazing! The pizza was the best I've ever had and I highly doubt I will be ordering from anyone except New York Pizza and pasta in the near future. This place is a gem. Seriously, you need to try this place. The restaurant is clean and the atmosphere is lovely. The wait staff is absolutely delightful and the food is outstanding. I can't wait to go back and try some of their pasta dishes. I liked it so much I got another 18 in supreme to bring home to those family members who missed out on our lunch today. I would give this place 10 stars. Update: Had to come back today and order dinner for the fam. Phenomenal as usual. Today we got a house salad (crisp and beautiful with their amazing house dressing), fried cheese (the marinara is so authentic it reminds me of the sauce my Italian uncle makes), spaghetti and meatballs (don't even get me started on how heavenly delicious these meatballs are) and an 18" meat lovers pizza. I'm in heaven!! Who needs olive garden when this little gem is hidden on Jones Creek?! ”
“ In my quest to find "really good pizza" I came across this place. You can taste the quality compared to other places. With that being said you will pay for what you are getting here. ”
“ I seen a video on TikTok and wanted to try them out. The service was very great and hospitable. The food was amazing I had a margarita slice and a pepperoni roll. Haven’t had good pizza like that in Baton Rouge in a long time. Definitely will be going back to try other dishes. My favorite part of the experience was being greeted by what seemed to be management/owner. 10/10 ”
“ If I could have 2 number 1 favorite restaurants in town, this would be my other choice. The food is exceptional, the service is always great, and it's one of the most professional businesses I've ever had the pleasure of dining in. The owner has personally greeted me every time I've entered the building, and I feel welcome and comfortable when I'm there. They do a lot of carry out business, but take the time and dine in with them if you get a chance. Had their play on Tiramisu, very different presentation than most, get some, and try it. You won't be disappointed. ”
“ If there were a way to give this wonderful restaurant a 10 star review it still wouldn’t be high enough - our family went in & we ended up having the place to ourselves & after we started eating it was shocking that it wasn’t packed - this family owned restaurant has the greatest food every dish we ordered was so very very good the customer service made us feel like family so if you are looking for a wonderful restaurant to eat at this place is perfect whether it’s for family meal, cozy intimate meal, a date whatever the occasion this is it but be warned your taste buds are in for major treat! We will definitely make this a must stop anytime we are in town!! If you haven’t been do yourself a favor & go!!! ”
“ The staff here are absolutely amazing. I ate so much food that I can't walk but it was worth it. 10/10 recommend. Order everything ”
“ LISTEN HERE AND LISTEN GOOD! Neal & I were on the hunt for some good new york style pizza and we are SO GLAD to have found such a GEM! New York Pizza and Pasta in baton rouge was MORE than a hit out of the park.... it was clean, DELICIOUS, and the owner was such a sweetheart! She served us personally, saw we were taking pictures and offered to get one for us. This pizza was TOP NOTCH. Little to no flop, perfectly charred but not burnt under carriage (one bite everyone knows the rules! )... it had excellent flavor and we will be back...often! Not to mention the pastas on their menu....from lobster ravioli to manicotti...what a dream! This service and experience was so much more than we expected and this small business deserves a PACKED restaurant!! Go check her out ”
“ My wife and I really like go out and enjoy a dinner together. We found this little place off of Jones Creek thinking we were going to get a pizza. When we arrived we saw that they had lots of other great Italian dishes which we tried.... been back and tried most of them. They have all been outstanding especially love the Red Sauce. The service is great everyone seems so joyful and glad that we are there. Highly recommend New York Pizza for your special night out. ”